When I first saw this post I was trying to work out if it was January 1st or April 1st that was approaching. Given that some forumites have looked at this as genuine, I should treat it with the same respect & pass on a couple of comments.
I really don't know about all this. I find lots of stuff under houses that I demolish all the time. Get a lot of coinage and generally it isn't worth a crock. I've found cutlery, money, wood, books, but mainly junk. I don't see how anyone would find this stuff a treasure trove. All the labels on the bottles are up sh1**ers ditch. The Penfold Claret is okay, even the Wolf Blass 76 and 79ers are okay. But its like a can of food without a label if you ask me. Some of these bottles have lead caps.
Finished digging out all the wine bottles and I believe you guys will consider some of this a bit of a tragedy. Cleaned off some broken bottles and I think three of them would have been Grange Hermitage and even I know that would make you guys cry. Fair bit of broken glass in there and that makes me wonder why a bloke would spend what seems like a fortune on what must have once been good booze and then just dump it under the house. I think there was a lot of subsidence in the house but it's still weird. Six of the bottles in the dirt appeared to have been in wooden boxes but they were rotted right through.
Keep in mind these wines that are being unearthed are quite old wines, so even if they are in good condition they will be quite different to the equivalent current vintages from your local booze outlet. They were probably made in a different style to the current batch of fruit bombs too - if you want a rough idea of what they could be like check out the free Rewards of Patience 5 available on the Penfolds website.
As far as keeping it under the house goes, if the wines have been preserved this long there's method in the guy's apparent madness. As long as they haven't been exposed for an extended time during the demolition, the wines could be in very good shape. I heard last week of a 1996 Grange that was taken to a wine clinic last year that was ullaging badly due to being kept under a bed - compared to that this guy was a genius.
Again while the label damage is regrettable it's a good sign they've been down there a long time - it's a pity the wines and boxes weren't elevated off the dirt and there wasn't any moth balls/insect repellant to minimise the damage. Keep that in mind when buying at action folks - damaged labels while being sometimes significantly cheaper could be a sign that someone has actually tried to cellar the bottles properly, and if you're actually buying the wine to drink that's a bonus.
Cheers
Ian
Forget about goodness and mercy, they're gone.