Page 5 of 6
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2015 10:35 pm
by rooman
Hacker wrote:rooman wrote:Great restaurant, lovely people just a pity I turned up on the wrong evening. Will make the trip back tomorrow.
You goose!!

You should have turned up last night, I was having a great time there. You didn't drink the '03 PC to drown your sorrows I hope!
As you will see from above, I was bloody tempted.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 4:14 am
by Polymer
At least you know the wine is ready to go

. Would've really been interesting if you had decanted it beforehand..haha..
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 7:06 am
by 9redpens
Gladstone 02 for me. Sorry about the crazy late notice, I had no idea what was in the fridge until now.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 7:58 am
by maybs
Hey guys, I've woken up with a headache, fever and shakes so unless I show marked improvement I won't be coming. Will confirm by lunch but it is unlikely.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:25 am
by mjs
Looking forward to the report/notes from this one!!
Five pages in the thread an no bottles opened yet (one broken unfortunately

)
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:28 am
by Croquet King
mjs wrote:Looking forward to the report/notes from this one!!
Five pages in the thread an no bottles opened yet (one broken unfortunately

)
I'm thinking of voice recording some notes this time. Every tasting I go to, I try and write them but always get distracted.
I can then type them up once I'm home and sobered up.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:39 am
by pc79
MrsC79 has thrown her hand up to be a late inclusion for tonight's festivities if there is still room?
rooman! Super effort, back to back SPN! Doh!
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:46 am
by Bobthebuilder
pc79 wrote:MrsC79 has thrown her hand up to be a late inclusion for tonight's festivities if there is still room?
rooman! Super effort, back to back SPN! Doh!
That would be great, even if mabys does pull together theres still that one more spot to take it to the originally planned 16.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 9:05 am
by odyssey
Very sorry to do this folks but I'm coughing and sputtering this morning (and now very drugged up)... in the interests of not sharing it around tonight, I think it best if I stay away...
Need to open this wine soon though, thinking of arranging an NZ-themed offline in the new year if there's any interest out there.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 9:10 am
by odyssey
mjs wrote:Five pages in the thread an no bottles opened yet (one broken unfortunately

)
And believe me I was half-tempted to taste it. If it was on a cleaner surface I probably would have risked death-by-tongue-splinter.

Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 9:16 am
by rooman
mjs wrote:Looking forward to the report/notes from this one!!
Five pages in the thread an no bottles opened yet (one broken unfortunately

)
Well that's not totally correct. I did open the PC yesterday to make sure it was ok after the Katnook. Last night it was tasting beautiful. i have recorked and hope it doesnt fall over.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 11:08 am
by Bobthebuilder
I'm heading down to the cellar now to find a bottle for the missus to bring
determined to find something from a region not yet in the line up
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 11:57 am
by andrewpc
Hi all, definitely still coming, but just a question on glassware. If I only own average glassware, should I bring it along or will the restaurant provide standard offerings?
Thanks
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 12:13 pm
by Bobthebuilder
Ok, Michelle's wine is a 2003 Domaine A, Coal River, Tasmania
Andrew, I think its part of a corkage negotiated deal(?), so best if you bring them along.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 12:24 pm
by Polymer
andrewpc wrote:Hi all, definitely still coming, but just a question on glassware. If I only own average glassware, should I bring it along or will the restaurant provide standard offerings?
I would bring it along....I'm sure they'll let us use some glasses there if we need to...given we'll have 14-16 people and pretty much everyone else will have their own glasses, I don't think they'll mind letting us use two.....I wasn't under the impression we had to bring our own glasses, just that we always do...
Either way you'll end up being a Zalto convert...maybe..probably..

Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 1:09 pm
by maybs
Just confirming guys I won't be able to make it. I'm falling apart at work, only here because I am under the pump. Gonna try and head home early and feel miserable on the couch.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 1:42 pm
by mjs
odyssey wrote:mjs wrote:Five pages in the thread an no bottles opened yet (one broken unfortunately

)
And believe me I was half-tempted to taste it. If it was on a cleaner surface I probably would have risked death-by-tongue-splinter.

^^

Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 2:06 pm
by dave vino
andrewpc wrote:Hi all, definitely still coming, but just a question on glassware. If I only own average glassware, should I bring it along or will the restaurant provide standard offerings?
Thanks
Am bringing 6 Zaltos you are more than welcome to have a couple. (assuming we are running max 2 per flight?)
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 2:58 pm
by TiggerK
Not wanting to step on CK's toes, but assuming we slot in the partners, any objections to this?? I just moved everyone down the list to keep it fair.
Table Cab
1. Dave Vino - (Margaret River - 2001 Houghton Jack Mann Cabernet, Coonawarra -1992 Lindemans Pyrus (probably)).
2. TiggerK - (Coonawarra Petaluma 1998 & a white)
3. Polymer -
4. Krusty - (Coonawarra Wynns Black Label 1990)
5. Bobthebuilder - (Heathcote - 2000 Wild Duck Creek - Alan's Cabernet)
6. Michellethebuilderswife - 2003 Domaine A, Coal River, Tasmania
7. RedSmurf - (Margaret River - 2000 Cullen Mag and an old Sauternes)
8. Hacker - (Coonawarra - Wynns Black Label 1991)
Table Sav
9. PC79 (Coonawarra Petaluma 2005 and Hawkes Bay - 1998 Coleraine)
10. PC80
11. CK (Coonawarra - 1985 Wynns John Riddoch, Margaret River 1995 Fermoy Estate)
12. andrewpc - Coonawarra - 2005 Balnaves of Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon The Tally Reserve)
13. rooman - (Bordeaux - 2003 Pontet Canet)
14. 9redpens - (Margaret River 2002 Houghton Gladstone)
15. Dingozegan (Orange - Canobolas Smith Reserve 2004, Bordeaux Chateau des Graviers Margaux 2009)
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 3:18 pm
by pc79
Sounds good here Tim,
I was bringing the 05 Petaluma to pair with your 98 to compare and contrast. Unsure if Bob would be happy to do a switcheroo - anyway, we can sort it all out when we get there.
Is anyone else bringing anything white?
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 3:44 pm
by Polymer
I'm bringing a white....Riesling..
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 3:55 pm
by dave vino
My OCD levels are really soaring with the 'probably' at the end of my wine every time....brown paper bag, inhale...

Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 4:42 pm
by Hacker
I will also bring bubbles to honor the occasion.
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 6:12 pm
by Hacker
Pretty sure Krusty isn't coming. He pulled out on Monday.

Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2015 6:26 pm
by TiggerK
Ok yeah did that in a hurry! So same tables but without Krusty then makes 7 on each...
Will be there 6.40
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2015 12:49 am
by pc79
Hacker wrote:Pretty sure Krusty isn't coming. He pulled out on Monday.

Soft
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2015 9:59 am
by Red Smurf
Great, Great night! Cheers all.
I think Paul (Sav table) and I (Cab table) were the only ones taking notes so I'll try to get some up soon.
Paul, hope you remembered to rip off that bit of table cloth you were taking notes on.
I'll just leave these here for now....
IMG_1968 bottles.jpg
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2015 10:28 am
by dave vino
Fantastic night, really cracking wines. Young, old and in between. Lots of regional typicity with something for everyone. From the 20+ year old wines that had no right to be so good (91 Wynns BL and 92 Pyrus) to the power and poise of the big hitter styles like Cullen, Jack Mann and Balnaves Tally to the sublime Pontet Canet. So many wines, so many good wines to boot, it makes me wonder why I’m not hunting down even more Cabernets. The 03 Domaine A was a surprise for me, really approachable and lovely to drink. The Riddoch was nice drinking. The 97 Rockford CabSav did well in representing the Barossa and won a few fans I hope. The Calon-Segur a nice counterpoint to the Cullen in a blind flight. I’ve missed a heap of wines, will need to see some pics to jog my memory.
Hackers champers was lovely as always, the man has a knack for picking out ones that tick all the boxes for me. (we have a very similar taste in champagnes) and the By Farr Viognier had lots of interest when we kicked things off. The Bests Riesling was nice also, very approachable even at a young age. Thanks to RedSmurf for the 75 Sauterne (Coutet?) which was a real treat and great way to finish off the evening.
Food was just right for me, lots of alcohol soaking up sized portions, done in a homely, familiar style. It really is a lovely place to enjoy your wines.
Great company and banter as always, sorry I didn’t get around to the other table apart from some brief forays, hope Andrewpc enjoyed the night and joins a few more outings.
Thanks to CK and TiggerK for the organising etc
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2015 2:34 pm
by rooman
Hacker wrote:I will also bring bubbles to honor the occasion.
David, I especially enjoyed the bubbles. Many thanks for bringing two bottles.
Mark
Re: November Offline - Sydney - Cabernet
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2015 2:58 pm
by Hacker
Super night, thank you all! Looking forward to Greg's notes - the way he was writing down stuff it was as though he was doing a 2000 word essay
Too many WOTNs to have one best, but my favs were the Pontet Canet, the 2000 Cullen, Dave's Rockford, and the Gladstones. All of these were on the plusher, sweeter spectrum as opposed to, say the Tally and Wynns BL which were stricter with a (healthy) acid kick. I just have a sweet tooth!
Sorry I snuck out early, but I'm sure you'll be pleased

I qualified for tomorrow's 36 holes.