Great company, great food and some lovely wines.
Champagne Grouping
1995 Krug
This wine easily won this grouping
It was initially quite stinky, with sulphur, and smokiness, and quite closed, but after 10 minutes in the glass, it really opened rapidly and was all at once magnificent and impressive, with yeasty, biscuity flavours, lemon, apples, apricots and roasted nuts (beautiful aged chardonnay dominates). Very long length. A perfect start to the night. I'm pretty sure I would drink this again in the future. WWOTN candidate.
Chardonnay Grouping
1998 Yattarna Chardonnay
Corked. (mea culpa)
2003 Stefano Lubiano "Collina" Chardonnay
An interesting contrast to the other chardonnays in this group, tight, minerally, flinty, very dry, and very crisp fruited. Lacked a little structure and length, but very drinkable, and went well with the 2nd course. Nice.
2003 Leeuwin Art Series Chardonnay (courtesy of Gavin)
Very minerally, with some sulphur, river stones, but the lovely yellow fruit is dominant (pears, apples, lemons, melon and grapefruit), with a firm, crisp acidic spine, and some fine spicey oak. Long finish with more than enough creme. World class. WWOTN candidate.
2004 Leeuwin Art Series Chardonnay (magnum)
I was surprised at the not-so-subtle differences from the 2003 (above). This was served very cold, and needed time to warm up before it sang.
Much more rounded and softer, lots more acidity, and lots more smokey oak, the fruit consists of gooseberries, pears, and peaches this time, lovely long finish. Fabulous.
WWOTN candidate.
Pinot Grouping
1999 Domaine Bruno Clair Gevrey Chambertin "Cazetiers" 1er Cru
Didn't know what to make of this wine. It seemed very closed, and lacked fruit, and mouth feel. Possibly faulty? Adrian assured me this bottle was very out of character.
2002 Bouchard Pere et Fils Beaune 1er Cru Vigne de L'enfant Jesus
Smokey and meaty, but very closed nose, and difficult to work this one out. Very subdued, almost austere palate, with red and black cherries, strawberries, dominant oak and acid. For a while I thought this might be faulty, but I now wonder whether it is just suffering from bottle shock. I would very much like to try this again, under different circumstances.
2004 Kooyong Estate Pinot Chardonnay
A good, honest, unpretentious Aussie Pinot, generous fruit, crisp acidity, some nice spicy oak, medium length finish. OK
2005 Domaine Noel Ramonet Chassagne Montrachet "boudriotte" 1er Cru Rouge
Very fruity, almost "New World" nose, medium bodied, red and black cherries, spicy oak, and plentiful acid. It lacks a little in structure and balance, may improve with more cellaring
Shiraz grouping
Shiraz is clearly alive and well in Australia!
1999 Kays Block 6 Shiraz
A lovely nose of tar, petroleum and plum. Lovely sweet core, with a little mint. Still has many years ahead of it. Contender for RWOTN
2001 Mt Edelstone Shiraz
Heady violets, smoke, and liquorice. Sweet syrupy core, lovely red and black fruit, beautiful definition, drinking very well right now.
2004 Best's Thomson Family Shiraz
Dense and very dark, powerful black fruited nose, a meaty and leathery palate, long nutty and savoury finish. Just sensational. RWOTN contender.
2006 Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier
Heavy floral (apricots) nose, medium-bodied, but very tight and closed, with palate showing very dry and subdued red and black fruit, abbreviated and disappointing finish. Very smooth but needs lots of time to blossom.
Cabernet (Blend) Grouping
1973 Redman Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon
Thanks to scanlon for bringing this along.
The bottle very much looked 35 years old, but the contents were in good condition.
Very smooth and savoury, a little chamois, still a little classy oak, and more than enough bright fruit and acid. Easily able to hold its head up high against the younger cabernets, I will remember this wine for years to come.
1992 Wynns John Riddoch Coonawarra Cabernet (magnum)
Beautiful Coonawarra Cabernet, powerful, dense, liquorice, tar, chalky tannins, boundless black fruit, and a finish that goes on into next month.
1993 Thomas Hardy Coonawarra Cabernet
Unmistakable Coonawarra aromas of capsicum, tobacco leaf, cassis and small black berries, but the palate was a little thin, and I thought disappointing in this class, but just enough interest to keep me coming back for a little more (hoping for some improvement). Outclassed here.
1996 Penfolds Bin 389
A good bottle, and really still a little youthful. The cabernet seems to dominate, the tannins already well integrated, the fruit is well defined, and the finish is very long. No disappointments here. Contender for RWOTN.
2002 Moss Wood Cabernet Sauvignon
Very, very young, in need of a long decant, remained very tight and closed through the evening. Chunky tannins, loads of cedary and vanilla oak, red and black fruit(dark cherries, plums, mulberries, and blackberries), and lots of acid. Great potential, but just barely drinkable on the night.
I left a few wines out, I'm sure Ian will cover these.
Cheers.
John.