The Auswine Forum

Another month...

3x David Duband Gevrey-Chambertin 2017

here's a big one!
A bottle of 1951 Penfolds Bin 1 Grange has sold for over AU$103,000

https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2020/07/bo ... -over-57k/

ok who was it?

Scotty vino wrote:here's a big one!
A bottle of 1951 Penfolds Bin 1 Grange has sold for over AU$103,000

https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2020/07/bo ... -over-57k/

ok who was it?

I don't have the time now, but The Age did a story about the 2019 Recorking Clinics in Melbourne last year. There was a chap, grandson I think of the original purchaser, who stumped up 3 perfect 51s...Gago said at the time he was one, speechless that there were three, and two, that all were in perfect condition.
He indicated a $60g plus result at auction should the vendor decide to test the market...I bet he has and one or both of the remaining two off the back of this result will most likely follow.
Cheers Craig

Scotty vino wrote:here's a big one!
A bottle of 1951 Penfolds Bin 1 Grange has sold for over AU$103,000

https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2020/07/bo ... -over-57k/

ok who was it?

What a bargain !

Hunter wrote:

Scotty vino wrote:here's a big one!
A bottle of 1951 Penfolds Bin 1 Grange has sold for over AU$103,000

https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2020/07/bo ... -over-57k/

ok who was it?

What a bargain !

Compared with what or simply a piss take

Cheers Craig

A few stray bottles of 2011...(yes the shittiest vintage in SA since the very wet 92 and equally poor 95) of Wynns BL
I went to a tasting function on release of the wine with poor Luke Skeer doing the marketing pitch, was like selling ice to Eskimos. He stated that a wine critic had it in his top 5 2011s across the country, yet don't believe said wine critic had that big a sample that vintage. I did not buy any on release, remembering it to be green, thin and bitter. Instead, I brought more of the 10 and 12 vintages.

Interesting year 2011, because any wine worth its salt (i.e. cue top marques) was not made in 2011, apart from Grange which even Gago through gritted teeth condemned. Strangely, Wendouree had a release too, have yet to try these either.

Anyway a very small make of BL that year, about 3000 cases vs. the standard volumes of 80-110 thousand cases.
Will try one when it arrives, and hope that time, palate or memory will be kind.

Cheers Craig

phillisc wrote:A few stray bottles of 2011...(yes the shittiest vintage in SA since the very wet 92 and equally poor 95) of Wynns BL
I went to a tasting function on release of the wine with poor Luke Skeer doing the marketing pitch, was like selling ice to Eskimos. He stated that a wine critic had it in his top 5 2011s across the country, yet don't believe said wine critic had that big a sample that vintage. I did not buy any on release, remembering it to be green, thin and bitter. Instead, I brought more of the 10 and 12 vintages.

Interesting year 2011, because any wine worth its salt (i.e. cue top marques) was not made in 2011, apart from Grange which even Gago through gritted teeth condemned. Strangely, Wendouree had a release too, have yet to try these either.

Anyway a very small make of BL that year, about 3000 cases vs. the standard volumes of 80-110 thousand cases.
Will try one when it arrives, and hope that time, palate or memory will be kind.

Cheers Craig

hmm 2011. In 2016 when i visited Katnook they told me they were one of the only ones to get their estate Cab Sav off the vine before significant rain made a mess of what was about to be picked in 2011. Be an interesting taste comparison to a 2011 BL.
The last Wendouree Offline we did in Adelaide I brought along a 2011 shiraz (only bottle under SC btw) and John Mack was a big fan. I think it was a pretty good example of how to let your wine making capabilites shine thru under trying circumstances. It wasn't the wine of the night by any means but it was still pretty solid.

Scotty V, was I at that offline? If so, would have made a note about the 2011. Cheers Craig

phillisc wrote:Scotty V, was I at that offline? If so, would have made a note about the 2011. Cheers Craig

yes mate here's your note;

2011, this wine polarised the group, John Mack absolutely loved it, and yes can see where he is coming from that it is a very good effort from a difficult vintage, but for the rest of us, it probably struggled. Very acidic on the palate almost medicinal, for those who have this vintage, open one up.

Scotty vino wrote:

phillisc wrote:Scotty V, was I at that offline? If so, would have made a note about the 2011. Cheers Craig

yes mate here's your note;

2011, this wine polarised the group, John Mack absolutely loved it, and yes can see where he is coming from that it is a very good effort from a difficult vintage, but for the rest of us, it probably struggled. Very acidic on the palate almost medicinal, for those who have this vintage, open one up.

Very good, must be loosing my marbles Might line one up when the 2011 BL arrives
Cheers Craig

2 x 2016 Oddero Barolo Villero
2 x 2016 Oddero Barolo Brunate

6 x 2015 Il Poggione BdM - at a great price, less than what I paid for the 2006 nine years ago.

brodie wrote:6 x 2015 Il Poggione BdM - at a great price, less than what I paid for the 2006 nine years ago.

Yes I find the Il Poggionw great value...I'm surprised given it seems a flagship wine.

cracks in the wall starting to be seen with Bordeaux pricing.
2014 selling below EP, and 2015/2016 at or just below EP in various auctions in US and HK.
as is always the case when you have investment houses selling pristine cases, retail will be obliged to follow to a point where the dfferential is inconsequential to the buyer.
with the dire Covid economy in front of us, those cracks might turn into large holes.

6 x 2010 Reschke Cabernet Sauvignon Empyrean
2 x 2016 Izway Shiraz Don

Anyone tried the Reschke and have views on drinking window?
Picked it up at a relatively good price from my local who was discontinuing the wine. Not much information that I could find but figured it should be decent as a flagship 2010 Coonawarra CS.

6 x 2015 De Bortoli Melba Reserve Cab.

bdellabosca wrote:6 x 2010 Reschke Cabernet Sauvignon Empyrean
2 x 2016 Izway Shiraz Don

Anyone tried the Reschke and have views on drinking window?
Picked it up at a relatively good price from my local who was discontinuing the wine. Not much information that I could find but figured it should be decent as a flagship 2010 Coonawarra CS.

Interesting story this one and will be careful that I don't invoke another call from the lawyers...but the 2 Reschke lads weren't all that happy after Trevor (their father) left a will that did not entirely favour the first born...and court action ensued. Number two son publicly left the business and got his own going with Koonara.
I well remember the first release of the Bos and the wine you purchased, at their debut fetching (or hoping) $100!!!! No pedigree...yes they sold good grapes to others but Sheesh. Punters were largely unkind and to be honest the brand has very little presence and has run out of steam. 8-10 year old wines on website largely reflects this.
I have tried a few over the years but it's a joke if it's considered in the same league as JR. If you got the wine for a good price...say $40 a bottle then it should be an enjoyable drink.
Let us know how it goes.
Cheers Craig

Thanks Craig. Appreciate your insights. I paid $75 vs the normal price of $150. They should have had some very good quality fruit to make it so hopefully still a nice wine, even if not worth anywhere close to the $150 asking price. I'll assume a 2020-2030 drinking window at this stage and planning to open a bottle this year - will post a tasting note here if I can remember.

Shit I just had a look on the website...it's now at $150...WTF!!!!
So at $75 at least a good discount for you. I am not surprised that your local is getting rid of it... until your post it's at least a decade since I had given the brand a thought, and I'm generally all things Coonawarra.
Cheers Craig

3 Unico zelo exocarpus Nebbiolo 2017
1 ravenswood Nebbiolo 2018
1 fletcher minion Nebbiolo 2018

The Aust Post man in a van has been ringing the doorbell a few times in the last couple of days, getting ready for another six weeks of lockdown with a few different cheapies

6 x 2015 Henry's Drive Shiraz Cabernet (Padthaway)
6 x 2014 Devils Lair The Hidden Cave Cabernet Shiraz (Margaret River)
12 x 2017 Longview Yakka Shiraz (Adelaide Hills)
12 x 2018 Thomas Goss Cabernet Shiraz (McLaren Vale)
12 x 2016 Allegiance The Artisan Trident Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet Franc Petit Verdot (Margaret River)

A case of mixed Marius'-second to last ever vintage.

6 X 2015 Sally’s Hill Cabernets

Bit of a post lockdown 2.0 buy for getting through the next few weeks.

1 x 2015 Cascina Pugnane 'Bussia' Barolo
1 x 2015 Cascina Pugnane 'Pugnane' Barolo
2 x 2015 Ar.Pe.Pe Valtellina Superiore Sassella Stella Retica
2 x 2016 Sandro Fay Valtellina Superiore Costa Bassa
3 x 2014 Antoniolo Gattinara
3 x 2016 Cantine Garrone 'Cà d'Mate' Valli Ossolane Rosso

A fine choice with the Antoniolo. For me they've been the best producer in Gattinara, but Giacomo Conterno owned Nervi aspire to that. Not cheap for the single vineyard bottlings mind, but the standard bottle remains fine value.

Just two bottles for me, from a natural wine specialist on Norwich market.
2017 Casa de Mouraz ALR Vinho Verde
2018 Ktima Ligas Pata Trava Pella - matching my hope they had something from Greece - maybe a Xinomavro? A Rosé, which can be a blind spot for me, but happy to give it a whirl.

Ian S wrote:A fine choice with the Antoniolo. For me they've been the best producer in Gattinara, but Giacomo Conterno owned Nervi aspire to that. Not cheap for the single vineyard bottlings mind, but the standard bottle remains fine value.

Cant find much info on their 2014 vintage of the Gattinara, so i was a bit hesitant, but seeing as I did try the 2013 Osso San Grato in June,
and it blew me away, I decided to take the punt.

Back from the first Margaret River trip for the year. Fantastic trip, often cellar doors were very quiet so ended up with long private tastings before another visitor walked in. Some stunning Chardonnays including the LEAS, Vasse Heytesbury and Cullen Kevin John.

Vasse Felix Margaret River Chardonnay 2018 x 2
Vasse Felix Heytesbury Chardonnay 2018 x 2
Vasse Felix Margaret River Semillon Sauvignon Blanc 2018 x 3
Vasse Felix Margaret River Cabernet Sauvignon 2017 x 4
Flametree Reserve Shiraz 2007 x 1
Cullen Wines Red Moon Mangan Vineyard 2017 x 2
Cullen Wines Chenin Blanc 2016 x 2
Cullen Wines Dancing in the Sun 2018 x 2
Leeuwin Estate Art Series Riesling 2019 x 2
Leeuwin Estate Art Series Sauvignon Blanc Semillon 2014 x 2
Leeuwin Estate Art Series Chardonnay 2017 x 2
Evans and Tate Karridale Chardonnay 2015 x 2
Evans and Tate Redbook Estate Chardonnay 2017 x 2
Woodlands Matthew Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 x 1

Rocky what did you think of the Woodlands lineup?

Hacker wrote:Rocky what did you think of the Woodlands lineup?

Hacker, I have been buying from Woodlands annually for past 10 years. Arguably the best winery and producer in Margaret River IMO. Their flagship CS, Margaret and Chardonnay are faultless.

They now have a nice seating tasting arrangement and option to buy cheeses to complement tasting.

Real down to earth and quality outfit.

Regards