Chatsfield 1999 Mount Barker Shiraz?

The place on the web to chat about wine, Australian wines, or any other wines for that matter
Post Reply
Guest

Chatsfield 1999 Mount Barker Shiraz?

Post by Guest »

Anyone try this or know anything about it?

This just showed up in my local wine shop for $10 US. It has all the signs
of a disaster. Too old a year for $10 new release, the label covered up by
the importers (Saint Paul, MN Wine Company) with another patch on the front label, and what I assume is an Aus animal on the label. (I'm still wondering where you keep those penguins :D )

WS and Parker seem to have passed on reviewing (which might be a good sign). Google shows there is a real winery by that name. The winery web site of course claims "The 1999 Shiraz has just won a silver medal at the London International Challenge. It has also been selected in the top 30 best Australian wines in the A$15 to A$25 price bracket." Hmm, no mention on this forum.

Since the fruit bombing of my area started about a year ago I've all but given up on Aus wines. 3 bottles poured down the sink after a sip; 3 more choked down. Given all this, I refused to try it even for $10 but a friend of mine did. I had one glass and, to my suprise, it wasn't bad for $10. A bit heavy on oak but none of overripe fruit bomb flavors I hate. Before I run out and buy a few any other opinions?

MartinE
Posts: 92
Joined: Sun May 09, 2004 8:47 am
Location: Brisbane

Re: Chatsfield 1999 Mount Barker Shiraz?

Post by MartinE »

Anonymous wrote:Anyone try this or know anything about it?

This just showed up in my local wine shop for $10 US. It has all the signs
of a disaster. Too old a year for $10 new release, the label covered up by
the importers (Saint Paul, MN Wine Company) with another patch on the front label, and what I assume is an Aus animal on the label. (I'm still wondering where you keep those penguins :D )

WS and Parker seem to have passed on reviewing (which might be a good sign). Google shows there is a real winery by that name. The winery web site of course claims "The 1999 Shiraz has just won a silver medal at the London International Challenge. It has also been selected in the top 30 best Australian wines in the A$15 to A$25 price bracket." Hmm, no mention on this forum.

Since the fruit bombing of my area started about a year ago I've all but given up on Aus wines. 3 bottles poured down the sink after a sip; 3 more choked down. Given all this, I refused to try it even for $10 but a friend of mine did. I had one glass and, to my suprise, it wasn't bad for $10. A bit heavy on oak but none of overripe fruit bomb flavors I hate. Before I run out and buy a few any other opinions?


No opinion but why not buy it??
...You like it, it's USD10/AUD13 and its got 6 years age on it.
Live dangerously...Lash out!! :wink:

Kieran
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2003 10:52 am
Location: Glebe, NSW

Post by Kieran »

Chatsfield is quite a reasonable winery. Halliday listed it as one of his ten dark horses in the 04 Guide. 02 Riesling and 02 Sticky have had raves.

In the 02 Guide he reviews the 99 Shiraz - it gets 87, drink roughly now, and describes it as a nice cool climate style with subtle oak. Seems fine for $10.

Kieran
"In the wine of life, some of us are destined to be cork sniffers." - Dilbert

Post Reply