Two Questions

[michel]

Keep it short and sweet
Only one wine for each question
The answers will vary over time

1. Best/most memorable/wine of your life currently ?

2. What would you most like to try that is kinda procurable without a Tardis?

For me

1964 Petrus
And
1999 Roumier Musigny

[Ozzie W]

1. Jacques-Frederic Musigny Grand Cru 2001
2. Any vintage of Domaine de la Romanée-Conti Romanée-Conti

[michel]

1. Jacques-Frederic Musigny Grand Cru 2001
2. Any vintage of Domaine de la Romanée-Conti Romanée-Conti

Jf mugnier 2001 is life awesome

[George Krashos]

1. Too many to choose from.
2. Penfolds Bin 60A 1962.

-- George Krashos

[Mahmoud Ali]

Short and sweet: I can only answer question one as question two is well nigh impossible, at least for me. Instead I will give you two answers for question one:

Most memorable wine: 1961 Chateau l'Arrosee, Saint-Emilion.
Most memorable Australian wine: 1982 Penfold's Bin 820.

Mahmoud.

[michel]

1. Too many to choose from.
2. Penfolds Bin 60A 1962.

-- George Krashos

George
The point is which one comes to mind
We all have a big list!
Go on
Name one!

[michel]

Short and sweet: I can only answer question one as question two is well nigh impossible, at least for me. Instead I will give you two answers for question one:

Most memorable wine: 1961 Chateau l'Arrosee, Saint-Emilion.
Most memorable Australian wine: 1982 Penfold's Bin 820.

Mahmoud.

You can only have one!
The 1961 is accepted
;-0)

[Mahmoud Ali]

Since my most memorable Australian has not been accepted I will choose one for question two, however with a Tardis, not without it:

The 1983 Penfold's Grange sometime in the far distant future when it really will be ready.

Mahmoud.

[michel]

Since my most memorable Australian has not been accepted I will choose one for question two, however with a Tardis, not without it:

The 1983 Penfold's Grange sometime in the far distant future when it really will be ready.

Mahmoud.

Geez Louise
I purchased that wine in a shopping trolley
For my 21st birthday
In the early 1980s
Incredible wine in evolution
Wow great call

[michel]

Short and sweet: I can only answer question one as question two is well nigh impossible, at least for me. Instead I will give you two answers for question one:

Most memorable wine: 1961 Chateau l'Arrosee, Saint-Emilion.
Most memorable Australian wine: 1982 Penfold's Bin 820.

Mahmoud.

You can only have one!
The 1961 is accepted
;-0)

What year did you have the 1982 820?
I had a bottle from cellar door ten years ago that was delightful and perfumed for 20 minutes then faded.

[Con J]

1 - Agree with Ozzie about Mugnier but I’ll have to go with the 1993 De Vogue – Bonnes Mares.

2 – A pristine bottle Giacosa red label from the 60’s or 70’s.

Cheers Con.

[michel]

1 - Agree with Ozzie about Mugnier but I’ll have to go with the 1993 De Vogue – Bonnes Mares.

2 – A pristine bottle Giacosa red label from the 60’s or 70’s.

Cheers Con.

This is more than brilliant
1993 vogue bonnes mares 2 years ago purchased in NZ thrilled a table of burgundy drinkers
However I hear the 1993 Vogue Musigny is not ready yet!
Any ideas on the Musigny?

[Con J]

1 - Agree with Ozzie about Mugnier but I’ll have to go with the 1993 De Vogue – Bonnes Mares.

2 – A pristine bottle Giacosa red label from the 60’s or 70’s.

Cheers Con.

This is more than brilliant
1993 vogue bonnes mares 2 years ago purchased in NZ thrilled a table of burgundy drinkers
However I hear the 1993 Vogue Musigny is not ready yet!
Any ideas on the Musigny?

I have two in the cellar but not had one yet.

Cheers Con.

[michel]

I have one
And it is being opened next winter
Fingers crossed

[Con J]

I have one
And it is being opened next winter
Fingers crossed

Should be great, looking forward to hearing about it.
One of my favourite producers.

Cheers Con.

[Hunter]

Im too young for an exception grand cru answer..
1. Chris ringland 3 rivers 1990
2. A first growth bordeaux. Any would do.

[Mahmoud Ali]

What year did you have the 1982 820? I had a bottle from cellar door ten years ago that was delightful and perfumed for 20 minutes then faded.

It was in 2004, making it 22 years old, and it was marvellous.

[Con J]

Im too young for an exception grand cru answer..
1. Chris ringland 3 rivers 1990
2. A first growth bordeaux. Any would do.

Had the 1994 Chris Ringland Three Rivers last Christmas.
It was a huge dense and powerful wine, liquorice and dark berry, very Grange like.

Cheers Con.

[phillisc]

Would like to have another look at a 55 Michael, 1984 was the last time
Agree any first growth would be awesome...even for a pleb like me a shit vintage would do.

Cheers
Craig

[Rossco]

1. Is a 3 way tie

1988 Wynns John Riddoch
1991 Wendouree Shiraz
1991 Rockford Basket Press


2. A Bordeaux or Burgundy that will blow my mind.
I have had good ones.... nothing life changing.

[michel]

1. Is a 3 way tie

1988 Wynns John Riddoch
1991 Wendouree Shiraz
1991 Rockford Basket Press


2. A Bordeaux or Burgundy that will blow my mind.
I have had good ones.... nothing life changing.

Try a 2001 Rousseau beze
Is still around

[JamieBahrain]

Henschke HofG 1990 well there were many others but this for consistency and what it means.

Bruno Giacosa Barbaresco Riserva Speciale Santo Stefano 1971

[TiggerK]

1. C. Marey & Liger Belair Musigny GC 1947 - Wow OK so this is why we have cellars and pay four figures plus for bottles of wine. Life changing stuff.

2..... DRC Romanée-Conti 1978 (or any old good vintage)

[Con J]

Bruno Giacosa Barbaresco Riserva Speciale Santo Stefano 1971

If you find one, I'll go you halves.

Cheers Con.

[michel]

1. C. Marey & Liger Belair Musigny GC 1947 - Wow OK so this is why we have cellars and pay four figures plus for bottles of wine. Life changing stuff.

2..... DRC Romanée-Conti 1978 (or any old good vintage)

Go cellar door to DRC they have been opening 1978 Echezaux!!

[Rossco]

1. Is a 3 way tie

1988 Wynns John Riddoch
1991 Wendouree Shiraz
1991 Rockford Basket Press


2. A Bordeaux or Burgundy that will blow my mind.
I have had good ones.... nothing life changing.

Try a 2001 Rousseau beze
Is still around

Cheers Michel, really appreciate that.

I will hunt the Armand Beze out!

[Hunter]

Im too young for an exception grand cru answer..
1. Chris ringland 3 rivers 1990
2. A first growth bordeaux. Any would do.

Had the 1994 Chris Ringland Three Rivers last Christmas.
It was a huge dense and powerful wine, liquorice and dark berry, very Grange like.

Cheers Con.

Yes pretty concentrated stuff..
I was fed 3/4 of a bottle while the sommelier i was with sat on 60 ml for 2 hours.

[Scotty vino]

Keep it short and sweet
Only one wine for each question
The answers will vary over time

1. Best/most memorable/wine of your life currently ?

2. What would you most like to try that is kinda procurable without a Tardis?

For me

1964 Petrus
And
1999 Roumier Musigny

oxymoron?

anywho,

1. Let's go with 1994 Wendouree Cab sav. Thanks Craig.
Plenty of others but the finish from this is still lingering in my mind.

2. 1982 Château Mouton Rothschild.
So much hype and craziness around this wine. Any first growth from that vintage would do.
Surely for the price tag it WOULD disappoint?

[Ian S]

Hmm I'm not especially excited about putting wines on a pedestal, but here goes:

Most memorable would probably be an old Chateau Chalon as it's a taste that is still very memorable years later, but let's discount that as it was very much in the 'interesting' rather than 'enjoyable category. So I guess I have to plump for an Avignonesi vin santo (don't recall the year) which is certainly the most intensely enjoyable wine I've tasted.

One I'd like to try? I'd have to say a German riesling TBA. Despite buying two halves from auction a few years ago, I never got to try them, as a friend took delivery for me, but before I got to pick them up, he had a diabetic friend round who found themselves in difficulty without insulin and he had no sugar in the house - before he remembered the TBAs. So I never did get to try one, and have yet to see any more at the sort of price I got them for. C'est la vie.

[Mahmoud Ali]

One I'd like to try? I'd have to say a German riesling TBA. Despite buying two halves from auction a few years ago, I never got to try them, as a friend took delivery for me, but before I got to pick them up, he had a diabetic friend round who found themselves in difficulty without insulin and he had no sugar in the house - before he remembered the TBAs. So I never did get to try one, and have yet to see any more at the sort of price I got them for. C'est la vie.

Really, a diabetic without insulin, in a house without anything other than a TBA?

Remiinds me of when my sister was in Rome and bought me a special bottle of wine. Because my sister was not going to be in Edmonton for a few months, her friend's father, who happened to be in Rome and was heading back to Canada, offered to take it. He comes through Edmonton on his way north and does nothing. He drinks it. Apparently he had some friends over and he "accidentally" opened the bottle. Fast forward a couple of years when I met him and his daughter at a dinner at my aunt's place he tells me the same story. Politely, I listen, nod, and ask him what was the wine. "I don't remember, but it was really good." My sister didn't remember the wine as it was recommended by the store. This is the sister who sent me a bottle of Palmer's second wine, a 1986 Reserve du General (now called Alter Ego) so it is left to my imagination as toi what it was.

Mahmoud.