Page 1 of 1
ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 2:40 pm
by newworld
Is There Really A Taste Difference Between Cheap and Expensive Wines?
http://www.forbes.com/sites/katiebell/2 ... ive-wines/It got me thinking when a Tahbilk wine got similar scores to much more expensive wine in a recent off-line reported on here recently.
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 4:04 pm
by odyssey
Whilst true that taste is not an exact science, I think pricing is also not an exact science. The regular Tahbilk Cab Sauvs have been outstanding QPR for about as long as Tahbilk has been in existence.... as good as many other wineries' premium offerings. The 1986 was one of the more memorable wines of the past 12 months and for some the WOTN in Nov last year.
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 4:23 pm
by sjw_11
IMHO many a $100 wine I have tried has been infinitely better than any $2 or $10-chuck ... but twice as good as a superior $50 wine? 5x as good as the best of the $20 brigade of wines that over-deliver for price? Hmm.... then again there is a label show-off value to account for...
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 4:35 pm
by Gavin Trott
Wow, great timing! Just spent and (always) enjoyable time chatting with Mike Press.
Loves telling the story of last year's Adelaide Hills Wine Show.
2010 Mike Press Shiraz, best Shiraz of show ... $12.50 per bottle
2010 Mike Press Shiraz, best Wine of show ... $12.50 per bottle
Up against $50.00 reds, $60.00 reds, and +$100.00 reds from the likes of Henshke, Shaw and Smith etc etc.
So some judges couldn't tell the difference either :--)
.
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 5:31 pm
by LawrenceM
Gavin Trott wrote:Wow, great timing! Just spent and (always) enjoyable time chatting with Mike Press.
Loves telling the story of last year's Adelaide Hills Wine Show.
2010 Mike Press Shiraz, best Shiraz of show ... $12.50 per bottle
2010 Mike Press Shiraz, best Wine of show ... $12.50 per bottle
Up against $50.00 reds, $60.00 reds, and +$100.00 reds from the likes of Henshke, Shaw and Smith etc etc.
So some judges couldn't tell the difference either :--)
.
I have two cases of the 2010 Mike Press Shiraz - great stuff for drinking now and for the next couple of years.
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 10:41 pm
by newworld
I have a carton of the 2010 MP shiraz, but I prefer the Cab (2008.) Mike agrees. He told me that CS is the star of the vineyard.
I guess I'm lucky that Halliday turned me onto MPW early in my wine buying life and set the bar (QPR) for me. I am eternally grateful to JH and MP!
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2012 10:51 pm
by daz
I found I preferred the MP cab to the shiraz too.
Re: ARTICLE: Is There Really A Taste Difference.....?
Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2012 8:48 am
by rens
Yes the Cab is a more elegant wine. Also my pick.