Best Merlot

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 12:33 am

Hi am interested to know what Australias best 2 Merlots would be on a consistant basis and also Frances best 2 {under $80 AUD}? Straight Merlot only please.

Cheers

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 9:03 am

Classic McLaren Wines 2001 La Testa merlot Very very delicious wine! You won't be dissapointed.

Give a Tony or Krys call on +61 8 83239551

707 · Post by **707** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 9:13 am

Irvine Grand Merlot has been producing the goods forever it seems and has had international success knocking off stuff like Petrus on occasions.

A wine that always does well whenever the Blacktongues do Merlot is the Penley from Coonawarra, verey consistent from vintage to vintage too.

Adair · Post by **Adair** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 9:34 am

The Irvine Grand Merlot seems to be the Australian Merlot with the largest reputation... and pricetag probably. The Petaluma is probably the other with the greatest reputation.

I believe Katnook can make a good one, and other Coonawarra producers are making serious attempts at straight Merlot and succeeding. You should probably investigate here further.

A Canberra producer called Kyeema is also doing good things.

You might be interested to read the following Merlot dinner presented by Attila:
http://www.auswine.com.au/forum/viewtopic.php?t=357

On the other hand, Australian Merlot to many people is like New World Sauvignin Blanc to me.

Kind regards,
Adair

Baby Chickpea · Post by **Baby Chickpea** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 9:59 am

Only one that I would ever buy (and do) - Wild Duck Creek Reserve Merlot. Lush, flamboyant, fruity but with great structure. lovely stuff! Not cheap at $90 but a cracker and WOW wine. This, from someone whose fave Bordeaux region is Pomerol!

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 10:39 am

Perhaps Howard Park "Best Barrels" would make it into this mix

smithy · Post by **smithy** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 10:45 am

A totally unbiased opinion on Aussie Merlot, would have Warrabilla at the top of the tree.
They are big, and only made in the best years (though the 2000 was one of the best). Alcohols are 15% +, and the newly released 2004 is right up there.

Price a mere $22 cellardoor.

For those who dispute this claim ( and they will be legion) I would happily put my 98, 00, 01 and 04 against ANY 4 Merlots in the country!

Cheers

Smithy

KMP · Post by **KMP** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 10:58 am

Miles wrote:"I am NOT drinking any F*@#king Merlot "

Now who's for a taste of the spit bucket?

Miles and I feel pretty much the same about a lot of Merlot. But I've cut and pasted a bit from my Blog on our Barossa trip because the Irvine Merlots are pretty good. We did not get to taste the big gun, the Grand Merlot. The Hotel is pretty rustic, so they probably do have a full spit bucket lying around somewhere!

On the way back to Tanunda we dropped into the Eden Valley Hotel for a bite to eat and a taste of some Merlot. In a corner of the main bar we shared mini pizzas and a glass of the three reds scrawled on the chalk board. The Irvine Spring Hill Merlot was a dense cherry red and fragrant with the perfume of violets. Soft and supple on entry, it was well balanced with the flavors carrying well on retronasal. (2, 2, 4.0, 10.0 = 18.0/20). The Irvine Eden Crest Merlot was a bigger, richer and more complex wine with attractive notes of blueberries and black currents. Soft and supple on entry, with vanilla present on retronasal, and a lengthy finish this was quite a nice Merlot. (2, 2, 4.2, 10.4 = 18.6/20). The Irvine Zinfandel was a dense cherry red with a briery, underbrush note and ripe fruit, and just a hint of ethyl acetate (volatile acidity). The mouthfeel was medium weight and the wine was well balanced with pleasing acidity and the flavors carried through on retronasal. (2, 2, 3.9, 9.8 = 17.7/20).

Mike

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 12:52 pm

I am a fan of the Petaluma Merlot 99 even though its young at the moment.01 has rated very well but seems like it wont be available forever.

Justin B. · Post by **Justin B.** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 1:34 pm

I would support Petaluma Merlot.

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 3:20 pm

I am not a great Merlot drinker but have enjoyed the Coonawarra Merlot from Peppertree. I think they now call it the Grand Reserve Merlot or some such "asking for a bigger price" name. The last one I had was the '98, I think, and it was very good.
MM.

Chow Chow · Post by **Chow Chow** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 3:28 pm

I've a soft spot for straight Merlot. The best I've drunk was Charles Cimicky Merlot 1998. Their 2000 isnt too shabby.
Another cracker is Evans & Tate Marlot. Their 98 & 99 are excellent.

I like the James Irvine Grand 1996 but the label comand a premium.

Craig(NZ). · Post by **Craig(NZ).** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 3:32 pm

and im being serious here. really why bother with $80 aussie merlot? Are you insane?? Why not one of the fantastic Hawkes Bay merlots? Esk, Villa Reserve, CJ Pask Reserve for starters

Really there is no contest NZ does way way better merlots than aussie. The Hawkes Bay style fits merlot like the Barossa Style fits Shiraz.

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Fri Feb 25, 2005 5:34 pm

I have a 98 Grand Merlot that i will open one day. Not sure how well it cellars?

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 11:43 am

Anyone tried the Gibson Reserve Merlot 2002? It's a blend of Barossa & Ad. Hills Merlot with 10% Barossa Cab. This is a (predominantly) Merlot I can really enjoy, full of character & beautiful structure, so do yourself a favour!

lantana

lantana · Post by **lantana** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 11:46 am

Gibson's sells for about $40 I think, less if you shop around!

lantana

Murray · Post by **Murray** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 1:05 pm

The 2001 Petaluma Merlot is fantastic. It was the indent release but there is some around the place at present; around $45-50/btl.

Jakob · Post by **Jakob** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 1:34 pm

Great, interesting topic. I've had Australian Cabernet and blends to match the very best of Bordeaux, but am yet to try a Merlot that came close to a good Pomerol. On that note, Murray you live in the area, have you tried the Farr Rising Geelong Merlot?

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 1:36 pm

Murray wrote:The 2001 Petaluma Merlot is fantastic. It was the indent release but there is some around the place at present; around $45-50/btl.

Where can you find this wine i have been waiting to get some?

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 2:54 pm

Jakob wrote: but am yet to try a Merlot that came close to a good Pomerol.

Jakob what would be the top three Pomerol Merlots you like? I am yet to try one of these and would like some hints on goodies.

Cheers

Murray · Post by **Murray** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 3:58 pm

Jakob wrote:Great, interesting topic. I've had Australian Cabernet and blends to match the very best of Bordeaux, but am yet to try a Merlot that came close to a good Pomerol. On that note, Murray you live in the area, have you tried the Farr Rising Geelong Merlot?

Sorry Jakob, I haven't seen the Farr Rising Merlot around the place is yet, but I'll see if I can check it out.

Murray · Post by **Murray** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 4:01 pm

Anonymous wrote:
Murray wrote:The 2001 Petaluma Merlot is fantastic. It was the indent release but there is some around the place at present; around $45-50/btl.

Where can you find this wine i have been waiting to get some?

If you bought it on Indent, the Indent shipment was delivered last August from memory.

Some retailers also bought it for retail sale, Gavin doesn't have it listed, but may be able to source it.

Jakob · Post by **Jakob** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 4:46 pm

For a good source of info, much better than I'd be able to offer, have a rake through:

http://www.wine-journal.com/pomerol.html

That said, my own personal top three: 1982 Trotanoy...achingly beautiful, almost a perfect wine. A 1980-something Lafleur-Petrus and 1990 le Bon-Pasteur have been wonderful too, though not quite at the same level as the Trotanoy. I had a bunch of 'cheapie' Pomerols while in Europe recently, and at the $30 level, probably half were very good wines. The diffficulty is getting them in Australia! The lower price bracket wines are virtually impossible to find, and even then the 200% markups make them unattractive. Auctions are probably your best bet.

Murray, thanks for that

Have been trying to find info after Halliday's 'right bank' comment in the 2005 guide!

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 5:00 pm

I wasn't going to mention Gibson's merlot but since Lantana mentioned so I will say something. His merlot isn't bad but nowhere near La Testa. During Wine Australia last year, Rob Gibson came over to Classic McLaren Wines stand and he didn't say much but I could tell he was quite impressed with La Testa wines including merlot. :wink:

And also, CP Lin (winemaker) from Mountford Vineyard, NZ said "La Testa Merlot was the most delicious and best merlot he has ever tried". This was also during Wine Australia last year.

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 5:41 pm

Anonymous wrote:Classic McLaren Wines 2001 La Testa merlot Very very delicious wine! You won't be dissapointed.

Give a Tony or Krys call on +61 8 83239551

How much per bottle is this wine?

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 5:44 pm

Murray wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Murray wrote:The 2001 Petaluma Merlot is fantastic. It was the indent release but there is some around the place at present; around $45-50/btl.

Where can you find this wine i have been waiting to get some?

If you bought it on Indent, the Indent shipment was delivered last August from memory.

Some retailers also bought it for retail sale, Gavin doesn't have it listed, but may be able to source it.

Out of curiousity what indent?

Chow Chow · Post by **Chow Chow** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 5:54 pm

Pay in advance, taking delivery at a later date.

btw. Geoff Hardy K1 Merlot(Adelaide Hills) isnt too shabby.

Baby Chickpea · Post by **Baby Chickpea** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 6:22 pm

Jakob wrote:For a good source of info, much better than I'd be able to offer, have a rake through:

http://www.wine-journal.com/pomerol.html

That said, my own personal top three: 1982 Trotanoy...achingly beautiful, almost a perfect wine. A 1980-something Lafleur-Petrus and 1990 le Bon-Pasteur have been wonderful too, though not quite at the same level as the Trotanoy.

Agree on the 82 Trot Jakob - one of my favourite wines of all time. Well describd but for me is impeccably balanced.

Guest · Post by **Guest** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 7:00 pm

Kays 2002 Merlot, very good example of warm climate merlot. Serious value too

cranky · Post by **cranky** » Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:31 pm

Here are my notes on Merlots from the Wine Appreciation classes I did last year.

I can highly recommend the Brown Bros Patricia 2002 from this lot.

Yering Station 2001 Yarra Valley $23 Bright opaque ruby, garnet rim. Rasberry and plum jam, spice, some smoky oak. Soft, full, Stewed plums with rasberry tones, dry leafy finish. 16.5.
Brookland Valley 2002 Show wine... reserve label? Margaret River $40+? Almost opaque dark, dark ruby with ruby/garnet rim. Earthy red capsicum with black fruit underneath. Soft approach to fairly strong tannins, silky feel, warm black fruits and cherries, some leafiness. Not complex, but well balanced. 17.
Chalice Bridge 2002 Margaret River $25? Almost opaque dark ruby/garnet. Cedar, blackcurrant, faintly cheesy, hints of rubber. Soft and full, silky tannin, red and black fruit, leafy, tobacco, cedar, dark chocolate. 18.
Fox Creek Reserve 2001 McLaren Vale $48 Opaque garnet, ruby/purple rim. Tight nose, cedar, pencil shavings, black olives. Soft approach, full, builds to astringent tannins and long very dry finish. Black tastes all over the palate... licorice, olives, assorted black fruits. Needs food and/or time to mellow (if it can!). 17-18.

Rosemount Orange 2002 Orange $24 Opaque dark garnet, garnet rim with violet hints. Herbs, cassis, sweet coconut oak. Blackcurrant, leafy, powdery tannins, a bit hollow, but long finish. 16.
Brown Bros. Patricia 2002 King Valley $46 Opaque, glass staining dark garnet, dark garnet rim. Closed to start, then beautiful dark chocolate, black cherry, rasberry, smoky oak. Soft, red fruits, pepper, coconut, subtle oak which becomes more pronounced at finish. Easy to drink! 18.

I have a 94 Petaluma which I may open soon, will post a note then.
However, one prize from auction is a 98 La Conseillante which I won't be posting a note on for a few years yet!

The Auswine Forum

Best Merlot

Best Merlot

Merlot

Why bother??